Blog · 6 min read

How to Choose a Digital Marketing Agency (12 Questions)

How to choose a digital marketing agency: 12 questions to ask, red flags to avoid and what a fair contract, report and price should look like.

How to Choose a Digital Marketing Agency (12 Questions)

In short

How to choose a digital marketing agency: 12 questions to ask, red flags to avoid and what a fair contract, report and price should look like.

In this guide

  • Questions about results
  • Questions about the work
  • Questions about ownership and contracts
  • Questions about fit
  • Warning signs
  • Step 1: Know what you need
  • Step 2: Build a shortlist
  • Step 3: Check their proof
  • Step 4: Ask the right questions
  • Step 5: Compare proposals fairly
  • Red flags to watch for
  • Specialist agency vs full-service agency
  • Local agency vs remote agency
  • What a good onboarding looks like
  • How to work well with your agency
  • Frequently asked questions
  • A simple agency scorecard
  • What to include in your brief
  • Questions agencies should ask you
  • How pricing models compare
  • The first 90 days with a new agency
  • Agency terms explained
  • Key takeaways
  • More questions about hiring an agency

Choosing an agency is a big decision. These questions help you compare options on what really matters: results, transparency and fit.

Questions about results

  • What results have you achieved for businesses like mine, and can I speak to a client?
  • Which metrics will you report on, and how often?
  • What should I realistically expect in the first 90 days?

Questions about the work

  • Exactly what will you deliver each month?
  • Who will work on my account, and will I have a dedicated contact?
  • How do you decide which channels to use for my business?

Questions about ownership and contracts

  • Will I own my ad accounts, website, content and data?
  • What is the minimum contract length, and how do I cancel?
  • What happens to my accounts if we stop working together?

Questions about fit

  • Do you understand my industry's rules and buyers?
  • Can you work in my time zone and market?
  • How do you handle it when something isn't working?

Warning signs

Be careful with agencies that guarantee rankings, won't explain their methods, keep accounts in their own name or lock you into long contracts before proving results. A good partner is open about what they do, what it costs and what you can expect.

Step 1: Know what you need

Before you talk to agencies, write down your goals (more leads, more sales, a new market, a new product), your budget range, your timeline and which channels you already use. Decide whether you need a specialist (for example, only SEO or only Google Ads) or a full-service agency that can run several channels together.

Step 2: Build a shortlist

Look for agencies that have worked with businesses like yours in your market. Good sources include referrals from people you trust, review platforms such as Clutch and Google reviews, industry associations and agencies you notice ranking or advertising well themselves. A shortlist of three to five is enough.

Step 3: Check their proof

  • Case studies with numbers: leads, sales, cost per lead and revenue, not just traffic or "impressions".
  • Client references you can actually call.
  • Reviews on Google and independent platforms.
  • Their own marketing: does their website load fast, explain things clearly and rank for relevant searches?

Step 4: Ask the right questions

  • Who will work on my account, and how experienced are they?
  • What will you do in the first 90 days?
  • How will you measure success, and how often will you report?
  • Will I own the ad accounts, website, content and data?
  • What is the contract length and notice period?
  • How do you communicate: calls, email, Slack, dashboards?
  • What happens if results are below target?

Step 5: Compare proposals fairly

Put proposals side by side and compare deliverables, not just price. One agency may offer more hours, more content or better reporting for a slightly higher fee. Look for clear, specific plans rather than vague promises.

Red flags to watch for

  • Guaranteed rankings or results. No one controls Google or Meta.
  • Long lock-in contracts with heavy exit fees.
  • They own your accounts, so you lose data and history if you leave.
  • Reports full of vanity metrics with no link to leads or revenue.
  • No clear plan for the first months.
  • Unusually cheap prices that rely on shortcuts.
  • Poor communication during the sales process, which rarely improves after you sign.

Specialist agency vs full-service agency

Specialists can be excellent at one channel. Full-service agencies make it easier to coordinate SEO, ads, content, social and email, share data between channels and report on overall return. If you need several channels, one accountable partner usually saves time and avoids gaps between agencies.

Local agency vs remote agency

A local agency may know your city well and be able to meet in person. A remote agency can bring specialist skills and experience from many markets. What matters most is whether they understand your market, which is why we build every campaign around the specific country, state and city you serve.

What a good onboarding looks like

  • A kick-off meeting to agree goals, targets and contacts.
  • Access to your accounts, set up properly in your name.
  • A tracking audit and fixes, so results can be measured accurately.
  • A written 90-day plan with priorities and deadlines.
  • A reporting schedule and dashboard.

How to work well with your agency

Give them access and information quickly, share sales feedback on lead quality, agree one point of contact on your side and review results together every month. The best results come from partnerships, not hand-offs.

Frequently asked questions

How much should I spend on a digital marketing agency?

It depends on your goals and market. Many small and mid-sized businesses invest $1,500 to $8,000 a month in agency fees, plus ad spend. Use our marketing budget calculator to estimate returns.

How long should I give an agency to show results?

Paid channels should show useful data within one to three months. SEO and content usually need six months or more for clear results.

Should I sign a 12-month contract?

Only if the terms are fair and you've seen enough proof. Many good agencies work month to month after a set-up period.

A simple agency scorecard

Score each shortlisted agency from 1 to 5 on these criteria, then compare totals:

  • Relevant experience: have they worked with businesses like yours, in your market?
  • Proof: case studies with numbers and references you can call.
  • Strategy: a clear, specific plan for your first 90 days.
  • Team: who works on your account, and their experience.
  • Transparency: ownership of accounts, clear reporting and fair contracts.
  • Communication: how responsive and clear they were during the sales process.
  • Value: what you get for the fee, compared with others.

What to include in your brief

A good brief gets you better proposals. Include your business overview, target customers, locations, goals and targets, current marketing and results, budget range, timeline, decision-makers and how you'll choose. Share access to analytics if you can, so agencies can make realistic recommendations.

Questions agencies should ask you

A good agency asks questions as well as answering them. Expect questions about customer value, sales process, lead quality, margins, seasonality, competitors and what has and hasn't worked before. If an agency proposes a plan without understanding your business, be cautious.

How pricing models compare

  • Monthly retainer: a fixed fee for ongoing work, the most common model.
  • Percentage of ad spend: common for paid media, but make sure fees are fair as spend grows.
  • Project fee: for defined work such as a website build or audit.
  • Performance-based: fees tied to results, which can work but may encourage short-term tactics.

The first 90 days with a new agency

In the first month, expect onboarding, audits, tracking fixes and a plan. In the second month, expect launches and early optimization. By the third month, you should see clear reporting, early results on paid channels and progress on longer-term channels such as SEO. If you're not getting clarity by then, raise it early.

Agency terms explained

  • Retainer: an ongoing monthly fee for agreed work.
  • SOW: statement of work, defining deliverables.
  • KPI: key performance indicator, a measure of success.
  • SLA: service level agreement, for example response times.
  • Full-service agency: an agency that covers several marketing channels.

Key takeaways

  • Define your goals, budget and channels before talking to agencies.
  • Ask for case studies with real numbers and references you can call.
  • Make sure you own all accounts, content and data.
  • Avoid guarantees, long lock-ins and vague plans.
  • Choose a partner who understands your market and reports on revenue.

More questions about hiring an agency

Should I hire an agency or an in-house marketer?

An in-house marketer knows your business deeply but can't cover every skill. An agency brings a team of specialists. Many businesses combine both: an in-house lead working with an agency.

What should a monthly report include?

What was done, results against targets (leads, sales, cost per lead), what's working, what isn't and the plan for next month.

How many agencies should I talk to?

Three to five is usually enough to compare approaches and pricing without wasting time.

Is it a red flag if an agency won't share prices upfront?

Not necessarily, since good pricing depends on your goals and market. But they should give you a clear, written quote after understanding your needs.

About this guide

This guide was written by the Reach US Direct strategy team, drawing on our day-to-day work running SEO and related campaigns for businesses in the USA, Canada, the UK, Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, Germany, the Netherlands, the UAE and Singapore. We update our guides when platforms, rules or best practice change. Figures such as prices and benchmarks are typical ranges, not quotes; your own numbers will depend on your market, industry and goals. Nothing in this article is legal or financial advice.

Get help with SEO in your market

Want us to put this guide into practice for your business? Start with a free audit, or see how we deliver Search Engine Optimization (SEO) in your country:

Free marketing audit

Ready to grow?

Tell us about your business and goals. We'll review your website, rankings, ads and competitors and send a clear plan within 48 hours.

  • Reply within 24 hours
  • No contracts, no obligation
  • A strategy built for your market
Thanks! Your request is in. Our team will reach out within 24 hours.
Something went wrong. Please try again or email hello@reachusdirect.com.
📞 Call UsGet Free Quote →